Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s Labour Government is facing accusations of a cover-up after the Ministry of Justice refused to release detailed criminal conviction figures for foreign nationals in England and Wales.

The latest refusal concerns statistics for 2025 and comes as the Government is already fighting a separate legal battle over the publication of similar figures covering 2018 to 2024.

According to a report published by the Mail on Sunday on 15 November, the Ministry of Justice rejected a Freedom of Information request from the Centre for Migration Control, citing concerns that releasing the information could identify individual offenders.

The think tank had requested conviction figures broken down by nationality and type of offence.

In its response, an official from the Ministry’s Analysis Directorate reportedly stated: “On balance the interests of the data subjects to safeguard personal information outweigh the legitimate interest in this case.”

The decision has prompted fresh criticism of the Government’s approach to transparency over foreign national offending.

Government fighting order to release seven years of crime data

The latest dispute follows an earlier Freedom of Information request covering convictions between 2018 and 2024.

On 22 June 2026, the Information Commissioner’s Office ruled that the Ministry of Justice had failed to justify withholding much of the requested information.

The watchdog concluded that figures involving fewer than five convictions could be withheld to protect personal information, but that the exemption did not apply to figures of five or more.

It also rejected the Ministry’s argument that the cost of producing the statistics exceeded the legal threshold.

Rather than release the figures, the Government appealed the decision to the First-tier Tribunal.

That appeal remains unresolved, leaving the requested breakdown unavailable while legal proceedings continue.

Campaigners accuse ministers of concealing information

Robert Bates, research director at the Centre for Migration Control, criticised the latest refusal.

He said: “It is outrageous that the Government is putting the data protection rights of foreign national offenders ahead of the British public.”

Mr Bates argued that the figures were necessary for a proper public debate about immigration, crime and community safety.

The organisation has accused ministers of attempting to conceal the scale of offending by foreign nationals.

However, the accusation of a deliberate cover-up remains a claim made by critics. The refusal to disclose statistics does not, by itself, establish that ministers have deliberately concealed evidence of criminality.

What the withheld figures would show

The requested data concerns criminal convictions broken down by nationality and offence category.

It is important to distinguish nationality from immigration status. Foreign nationals convicted of offences can include long-term residents, visitors and people with different immigration backgrounds.

Conviction figures alone would not establish whether immigration increases or decreases crime rates without further analysis of population sizes, age profiles and other factors.

Nevertheless, the dispute raises questions about the public’s access to official criminal justice statistics and the balance between transparency and individual privacy.

The Ministry of Justice has previously defended its decision to appeal the Information Commissioner’s ruling and declined to comment on ongoing legal proceedings.

The department, led by Justice Secretary Alex Norris, is responsible for handling the requests, while Andy Burnham has served as Prime Minister since July 2026.

The outcome of the tribunal appeal could determine whether the Government must disclose the historical conviction figures.

The separate refusal covering 2025 has added further pressure on ministers to explain why the requested information cannot be published in a form that protects individual identities.

 

We are your go-to destination for breaking UK news, real-life stories from communities across the country, striking images, and must-see video from the heart of the action.

Follow us on Facebook at for the latest updates and developing stories, and stay connected on X (Twitter) the for live coverage as news breaks across the UK.

SIGN UP NOW FOR YOUR FREE DAILY BREAKING NEWS AND PICTURES NEWSLETTER

Your information will be used in accordance with our Privacy Policy

YOU MIGHT LIKE