A High Court judge ruled last week that doctors could legally stop treating Archie Battersbee, but lawyers for the family argued in court on Monday that a higher burden of proof should have been used.
They also questioned whether Mrs Justice Arbuthnot considered the youngster’s religion before making her decision on June 13.
Archie has been in an induced coma since being discovered unconscious at home on April 7, but his parents, Hollie Dance and Paul Battersbee of Southend, Essex, believe his heart is still beating and have petitioned the Court of Appeal.
Ms Dance and Mr Battersbee, who are divorced, asked Mrs Justice Arbuthnot for permission to file an appeal at a High Court hearing on Monday.
Before a full appeal hearing could be held, they had to establish that they had an arguable or compelling case.
A barrister who led their legal team argued that the evidence did not prove Archie’s death “beyond reasonable doubt.”
According to Edward Devereux QC, the decision was made on the basis of a balance of probabilities.
He contended that a decision of this “gravity” should have been made “beyond reasonable doubt.”
Mrs Justice Arbuthnot decided that the standard of proof issue should be considered by appeal judges.
She claimed that the Court of Appeal had never considered the standard of proof issue in “declaration of death” cases.
According to the judge, that issue provided a compelling reason for appeal judges to consider the case.
Doctors at the Royal London Hospital treating Archie believe he is “brain-stem dead,” according to Mrs. Justice Arbuthnot.
They believe Archie’s treatment should come to an end and that he should be removed from the ventilator.
Archie’s parents say his heart is still beating and that he should continue receiving treatment.
Lawyers for the Royal London Hospital’s governing trust, Barts Health NHS Trust, asked Mrs Justice Arbuthnot to decide what steps were best for Archie.
20
Never miss another Breaking story again
You can sign up to get the latest news, top stories and exclusives sent straight to your WhatsApp from the UKNIP team.
WhatsApp
Instagram
Snapchat
To get stories sent to you, you need to already have WhatsApp. All you need to do is click this link and select ‘join community’
No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the UKNIP team. you can read your privacy policy notice.
Click here to join our WhatsApp community.
Follow UKNIP
READ NEXT:
Most Read
-
Major Police Operation Leads to Discovery of Stolen Goods and Multiple Arrests in Cranbrook
-
Four Arrested and One Dead After Medical Incident in North Devon
-
Matthew Sparkes Jailed After Causing Major Pile-Up on A2 in Gravesend
-
A man has been arrested on suspicion of causing grievous bodily harm after a woman suffered stab wounds in Brent
-
Detectives investigating reports of a serious assault in Higham are appealing for witnesses