Force Admits No Evidence of Jewish Backing for Maccabi Fan Ban
West Midlands Police have been forced to publicly apologise to MPs after wrongly claiming that members of Birmingham’s Jewish community supported the ban on Maccabi Tel Aviv fans at Aston Villa’s Europa League clash.
Chief Constable Craig Guildford told the Home Affairs Select Committee there was actually “no documented feedback from Jewish representatives” before the controversial ban was imposed on November 6, 2025.
The findings are expected by March 31, 2026.
The match itself saw over 700 officers deployed and concluded peacefully with Aston Villa beating Maccabi 2-0. However, UEFA fined Maccabi €20,000 (£17,500) and issued a suspended away ban over discriminatory chants by their fans.
Damage Done to Trust Over Policing and Community Relations
Critics say the ban set a worrying precedent, letting potential threats dictate attendance rather than targeting troublemakers. The recall of Chief Constable Guildford to Parliament highlights how seriously MPs view the police’s bungled handling of both the ban and their subsequent testimony.
More from West Midlands Police
View all West Midlands Police coverage
- West Midlands Police Launch Major Crime Crackdown
- Manhunt Underway for Warwickshire’s Mohammed Khan Over Threats to Kill
- Lorry Overturns in Birmingham After Wild Police Chase
- Gang Tries to Snatch Motorbike in Broad Daylight
- Body Found in River Derwent Believed to Be Missing Birmingham City Fan
- Shocking Assault Case Unfolds on Tonight’s Forensics: The Real CSI
More from West Midlands Police
View all West Midlands Police coverage
- West Midlands Police Launch Major Crime Crackdown
- Manhunt Underway for Warwickshire’s Mohammed Khan Over Threats to Kill
- Lorry Overturns in Birmingham After Wild Police Chase
- Gang Tries to Snatch Motorbike in Broad Daylight
- Body Found in River Derwent Believed to Be Missing Birmingham City Fan
- Shocking Assault Case Unfolds on Tonight’s Forensics: The Real CSI
More from West Midlands Police
View all West Midlands Police coverage
- West Midlands Police Launch Major Crime Crackdown
- Manhunt Underway for Warwickshire’s Mohammed Khan Over Threats to Kill
- Lorry Overturns in Birmingham After Wild Police Chase
- Gang Tries to Snatch Motorbike in Broad Daylight
- Body Found in River Derwent Believed to Be Missing Birmingham City Fan
- Shocking Assault Case Unfolds on Tonight’s Forensics: The Real CSI