Cop Cleared After Tasing 10-Year-Old Girl Armed with Shears
The Shocking Streatham Stand-off
Police Constable Jonathan Broadhead of the Metropolitan Police Service has been cleared of gross misconduct after using a Taser on a 10-year-old girl in Streatham, south-west London. The drama unfolded on 21 January 2021 when officers were called to a home where the girl threatened her mother with gardening shears and a hammer.
PC Broadhead ordered the girl to drop the dangerous tools. When she ignored the commands and started climbing a staircase, he fired his Taser twice to subdue her.
What Happened Next?
- The girl was handcuffed and arrested for assault but later de-arrested.
- She received medical treatment for minor injuries caused by the Taser barbs.
- The Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) launched an investigation after the girl’s father filed a complaint.
Panel Backs Officer’s Actions
After a grueling four-day hearing, a disciplinary panel reviewed bodycam footage, witness statements, and PC Broadhead’s interview. They found his use of force was necessary, reasonable, and proportionate—no breach of professional standards.
CPS Refuses to Press Charges
The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) examined the case for criminal charges but chose not to prosecute. The family’s request for a review upheld this decision.
IOPC Stresses Public Confidence
The IOPC deemed the misconduct hearing essential for public trust in policing. Mel Palmer, IOPC regional director, said the independent chairperson was the right authority to rule on the case.
Adequate Aftercare Provided
The child was treated promptly—paramedics removed the Taser barbs, and handcuffs were used to prevent further injury.
Final Word
This controversial case sheds light on the difficult decisions police face when dealing with minors in crisis. The panel’s ruling brings closure and reinforces the need to judge police actions fairly in tense, high-pressure moments.
