A Metropolitan Police Service (MPS) officer, Police Constable Jonathan Broadhead, has been cleared of gross misconduct in a case involving the use of a Taser against a 10-year-old girl.
The Incident
The incident occurred on 21 January 2021, when PC Broadhead responded to a call in Streatham, south-west London. The police were informed that the girl was armed with gardening shears and a hammer, threatening her mother. Upon arrival, PC Broadhead instructed the girl to drop the shears, but she did not comply and began ascending a staircase, prompting him to Taser her twice.
Aftermath and Investigation
The girl was initially handcuffed and arrested for assault but was later de-arrested and received medical attention for minor injuries from the Taser barbs. The Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) initiated an investigation in March 2021 after the girl’s father filed a complaint.
Panel’s Conclusion
After a thorough four-day hearing and review of evidence, including body-worn video footage, witness statements, and PC Broadhead’s interview, the disciplinary panel concluded that PC Broadhead did not breach the police standard of professional behavior concerning the use of force. The panel determined that his use of the Taser was necessary, reasonable, and proportionate under the circumstances.
Crown Prosecution Service Decision
The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) reviewed the case for potential criminal charges against PC Broadhead but decided not to charge him, a decision that was upheld after a review requested by the child’s family.
IOPC’s Role
The IOPC presented the case at the disciplinary hearing, believing it to be in the public interest and crucial for enhancing public confidence in the police complaints process. Mel Palmer, IOPC regional director, expressed that the panel’s independent and legally-qualified chairperson was the appropriate authority to determine the outcome of the gross misconduct allegation.
Findings on Aftercare
The IOPC found that adequate aftercare was provided to the child post-incident, including calling paramedics to remove the Taser barbs and keeping her in handcuffs to prevent further pain.
Conclusion
The case highlights the complexities involved in policing, particularly when minors are involved. The panel’s decision brings closure to the case while underscoring the importance of evaluating police actions in high-pressure situations.
